Home  |  About Us  |  Articles  |  Devotional  |  Resources  |  Publications  |  Community  |  Sitemap
Wikipology.org
Wikipology.org
False Teachers EXPOSED! False Teachers EXPOSED! Sword Forums.net Gideon's Sword Forums Gideon's Sword Chat Live Chat Search the Web Search the Web
 
 

 
 
 

Paul McGuire

A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing

On a December 2005 broadcast of Paul McGuire's radio show, which currently broadcasts in southern California and St. Louis, the topic for the evening was the failure of certain department store chains failing to recognize the purpose of celebrating the Christmas season (which is the birth of Jesus Christ). At the time of the show Wal-Mart, K-Mart, and Target stores were accused of anti-Christian values. There were several call-ins threatening to boycott these stores. There were others calling in from the front-lines of the battlefield who were picketing a Wal-Mart store in California. The main issue it seems, is that the district managers of these stores, in an effort to present themselves as acceptable to all religions, were forbidding the use of the phrase "Merry Christmas" when greeting customers.

    I'm sure many people were listening furiously to the testimonies of those who went to one of these stores in the "Christmas spirit", only to be crushed by an insensitive "happy holidays" as they left the store. But the more I listened to the hype over this issue, I became angry with the message that was being sent to the tens of thousands of potentially un-saved people that were listening to this show.

    I called in to the show and made a statement to see if I could get the more important issue to be presented… the gospel of Jesus Christ. My statement was (paraphrased); "As Christians, isn't it our responsibility to preach the gospel. And if so, shouldn't we be doing that instead of arguing over principles? If we were to preach the gospel, and these managers were to be saved, they probably wouldn't have an problem standing up for Jesus and saying merry Christmas to customers." And I hung up. As I expected, my statement was not very well accepted. Paul McGuire said (paraphrased); "This kind of viewpoint is a "piest" viewpoint, these people tend to compartmentalize things as spiritual and non-spiritual". I was shocked. I listened to Mr. McGuire ramble for a couple of minutes about how Piests believe they should separate themselves from the world and never share the truth. I decided I had to call back. The call screener asked Mr. McGuire if he would take a second call from me and he obliged. When I was welcomed back on the air I said (paraphrased): "That was pretty much the answer I expected from a Dominionist like yourself". He responded; "I am not a Dominionist, I'm not working toward a Theocracy."

(I would like to add here; my intention with this conversation was not to belittle Mr. McGuire or argue over doctrine or principles. My intention was to expose Paul McGuire for the Catholic Reformed Dominionist he is; and present the truth to the listeners who may have been deceived by his false gospel.)

    For the next approximately half hour, Paul McGuire and I debated the "kingdom of Christ" issue. Paul McGuire's stance is that since God created everything, and God is Spirit, then all things are spiritual. Since we are God's ambassadors to earth, it is the Christian's responsibility to dominate the earth and it's systems. THIS IS DOMINION THEOLOGY! And Paul McGuire, although he denies it, is a Dominionist. We debated the subject through a couple of commercial breaks, then Mr. McGuire ended the show with a recorded sermon by Francis Schaeffer on the subject of "The Culture War".

    Many Christians today are being influenced by men like Paul McGuire who are teaching this heresy. Today there is a "Culture War" going on between the "liberals" and the Conservative Christians", but this is nothing but a political war. The only thing this political war is going to accomplish is to change the moral standard of society; it does NOTHING to exalt the name of Jesus Christ. There are a couple of points that I touched on in my conversation with Paul McGuire that I would like to elaborate on here.

    First, it needs to be understood that repentance of sin is something that is granted by God, it is not something that can be induced into society to make that society more godly (Acts 11:18, 2Tim 2:25). Repentance of sin is also only expected of a child of God. We should never overstep our boundaries where God is concerned. Our job as a Christian is to present the Gospel, not to try and mold a culture to our beliefs, that is God's job. By forcing or coercing the managers of Wal-Mart to repent and acknowledge Jesus Christ as the reason for the Christmas holiday, you are practicing dominion.

    Secondly this piest worldview, according to Paul McGuire is guilty of compartmentalizing certain things as spiritual and other things as non-spiritual, such as the world. We are apparently being accused of alienating ourselves from the world, and thereby unable (or unwilling) to effect the world in a positive way. The truth is, we do not alienate ourselves from the world; we are to be in the world, as the salt and light of the world. This doesn't mean we are to take the moral standards we acquire from Jesus and impose them on the world, but we are to show the world Jesus.

    Jesus is the embodiment of truth, wisdom, understanding and righteousness. Any truth we try to convey to the world apart from simply presenting Jesus Christ Himself, is not truth - it is a social philosophy. Any righteousness we try to convey to the world is nothing but socially acceptable behavior. Any wisdom we try to convey to the world, if it is not in the context of Jesus Christ Himself - it is total darkness. If you are opposing the principles and humanistic doctrines of the world, and you are not presenting Jesus, you are nothing but a hypocrite. You are essentially presenting truth, wisdom, understanding, and righteousness as if it were some attribute of yourself.

John W. Hardin

 

© 2006 Gideon's Sword Ministries - All Rights Reserved 

Over 3 Million hits on this site since 3/1/06